Article — Tips & Tricks · November 7, 2026 · 14 min read

House Siding Buying Guide: Vinyl, Fiber Cement, Wood and Brick Compared

Vinyl is cheap and nearly maintenance-free, fiber cement lasts 50 years, wood is beautiful and demanding, brick is forever — the right siding is a 30-year decision, and the cost per square foot is only the first number that matters.

For most American homes, fiber cement is the best siding material overall: it costs $6 to $12 per square foot installed, lasts 50 years or more, resists fire, rot, and insects, and holds paint for 10 to 15 years. Vinyl is the budget winner at $3 to $8 per square foot installed and needs almost no maintenance, wood is the classic choice for historic homes at $8 to $15 but needs repainting every 5 to 7 years, and brick is the most durable and most expensive at $10 to $20. Measure your home first with the Square Footage Calculator, calculate the wall area you will side with the Wall Area Calculator, compare repainting costs in the exterior painting cost guide, and prep the surface properly with the exterior painting prep guide if your current siding needs paint before you decide.

Suburban house exterior with new light-gray fiber-cement siding and white trim

Vinyl vs fiber cement vs wood vs brick: cost, lifespan, and what each one demands

Pick vinyl if budget and low maintenance matter most, fiber cement if you want the longest lifespan and the best fire resistance, wood if you own a historic home where authenticity matters, and brick if you want a siding that outlasts the house itself — that is the decision in one sentence. Vinyl siding is PVC plastic formed into panels: it costs $3 to $8 per square foot installed, it never needs painting, it resists moisture and insects, and it lasts 20 to 40 years. Its weaknesses are that it can crack in extreme cold (below -10°F, or -23°C, it becomes brittle), it can warp in extreme heat if a dark color is used, and it dents when hit by a hailstone or a thrown ball. Fiber cement siding (the best-known brand is James Hardie) is a mix of cement, sand, and cellulose fiber pressed into boards: it costs $6 to $12 per square foot installed, it lasts 50 years or more, it is non-combustible (it will not burn), it resists rot, insects, and hail, and it holds paint for 10 to 15 years. Its weaknesses are weight (it is heavy and needs two installers to handle a board) and cost — it is roughly double the price of vinyl installed. Wood siding (clapboard, shingle, or board-and-batten) costs $8 to $15 per square foot installed, it looks right on a colonial, craftsman, or farmhouse, and it can be painted or stained any color. Its weaknesses are maintenance (paint every 5 to 7 years, stain every 3 to 5 years), rot, and insects — wood siding that is not maintained will rot at the bottom edge and behind the trim within 10 to 15 years. Brick veneer costs $10 to $20 per square foot installed, it lasts 75 to 100 years with almost no maintenance, it is fireproof, and it is the most durable siding of all. Its weaknesses are cost (the most expensive of the four) and weight — a brick veneer needs a concrete footing or a steel lintel to support it, which adds $2,000 to $5,000 to the job if the house was not built for brick.

For a typical 2,000 sq ft two-story home with about 1,500 sq ft of wall area, the totals work out to $4,500 to $12,000 for vinyl, $9,000 to $18,000 for fiber cement, $12,000 to $22,500 for wood, and $15,000 to $30,000 for brick. Those totals include removal of the old siding ($1,000 to $3,000), house wrap and flashing ($500 to $1,500), and trim, but they do not include replacing rotted sheathing underneath — and a siding job often reveals rotted sheathing, which costs $50 to $100 per sheet to replace, plus labor. Budget a 10 percent contingency for sheathing repairs, because a contractor who finds rot and stops work to renegotiate is a contractor who will charge you more than one who is told in advance to fix what he finds up to a stated limit. Also consider the resale return: national remodeling data puts the return on a siding replacement at 70 to 80 percent of the job cost, which is among the highest of any exterior project, and fiber cement consistently ranks at the top of that list — a $15,000 fiber cement job typically adds $10,500 to $12,000 to the home's value, while also cutting the buyer's worry about future maintenance.

How much siding you need: measuring walls, gables, and waste

Measure each wall as a rectangle (length times height) and add the gable triangles (half the base times the height), then subtract the doors and windows and add 10 percent for waste — that formula gives you the siding area within 5 percent, which is close enough to get an accurate quote. A typical two-story home has 1,200 to 2,000 sq ft of siding area, and a single-story ranch has 800 to 1,200 sq ft. Measure the length of each wall along the ground, measure the height from the foundation to the eave (and to the peak for a gable), and record each wall separately — a wall that is 40 ft long and 18 ft tall (two stories at 9 ft each) is 720 sq ft, and a gable triangle that is 40 ft wide and 6 ft tall adds 120 sq ft (half of 40 times 6). Subtract the windows and doors: a standard window is about 15 sq ft, a standard door is about 21 sq ft, and a typical home has 10 to 15 windows and 2 to 3 doors, which subtracts 200 to 300 sq ft. Add 10 percent for cutting waste, and add another 5 percent if the house has a lot of corners, dormers, or angles, because every cut wastes a piece of siding. Siding is sold by the square (100 sq ft), so a 1,500 sq ft job needs 15 squares plus waste, or about 17 squares total.

Order the material only after the contractor has measured, because a contractor who orders from your measurements will blame your measurements when the material runs short. Ask the contractor for a written takeoff (the list of material quantities) and compare it with your own calculation — if the contractor's number is 20 percent higher than yours, ask why, and if it is 20 percent lower, ask whether he has allowed for waste. Confirm that the quote includes the house wrap (a water-resistant barrier that goes under the siding, $0.50 to $1.00 per square foot installed), the flashing around windows and doors, the starter strip, the J-channel around the openings, the corner posts, and the soffit and fascia if they are being replaced — those accessories add $1,000 to $2,500 to a typical job and are often left out of a low quote. Confirm the color and the profile (the shape of the siding, such as Dutch lap, beaded, or board-and-batten) in writing, and ask to see a full-size sample on the house before the order is placed — a 6 in sample cannot show you how a color looks across a 40 ft wall in afternoon sun, and a dark vinyl color that looks rich in a sample can look almost black on a whole house.

Climate, maintenance, and fire: what your region demands from siding

Choose siding for your climate, because the material that is perfect in Ohio can fail in Florida or Arizona. In hot, sunny climates (Arizona, Nevada, Texas, Florida), vinyl can warp and fade — choose a light color, which reflects heat and fades less, or choose fiber cement, which does not warp at any temperature and holds its color for 15 years. In cold climates (Minnesota, Maine, North Dakota), vinyl becomes brittle below -10°F and can crack if hit, while fiber cement and wood perform well and brick is excellent. In wet climates (the Pacific Northwest, the Gulf Coast), wood siding rots unless it is painted and sealed on all six sides (front, back, both edges, and both ends), and vinyl and fiber cement are the safer choices. In wildfire-prone areas (California, Colorado, Oregon), fiber cement and brick are the only choices that make sense — fiber cement is non-combustible and brick is fireproof, while vinyl melts and wood burns. Check your local building code before ordering: some wildfire zones require non-combustible siding by law, and some coastal zones require siding rated for hurricane winds (fiber cement and vinyl both have wind ratings up to 150 mph when installed to the manufacturer's instructions, but the rating depends on the fastener spacing, which the installer must follow exactly).

Maintenance is the hidden cost that decides whether a siding lasts its rated lifespan or fails in half the time. Vinyl needs the least: wash it once a year with a garden hose and a soft brush (or a pressure washer on low pressure, under 1,500 psi, held at least 12 in from the surface — a pressure washer held too close will drive water behind the siding and crack the panels). Fiber cement needs repainting every 10 to 15 years, which costs $3,000 to $6,000 for a typical home, and the caulk at the joints needs checking every 2 to 3 years. Wood needs the most: paint every 5 to 7 years ($3,000 to $7,000), stain every 3 to 5 years, and an annual inspection for rot at the bottom edge, behind the trim, and around the windows — a soft spot found early costs $50 to $200 to repair, a soft spot found late costs $1,000 to $3,000 in sheathing and framing repairs. Brick needs the least maintenance of all: repoint the mortar joints every 25 to 30 years ($1,000 to $3,000) and wash it occasionally. Whatever material you choose, keep the bottom edge of the siding at least 6 in above the ground and at least 2 in above any roof or deck surface — siding that touches the ground wicks moisture, rots, and gives insects a path into the wall, and a 6 in clearance is required by most building codes.

Siding material samples side by side: vinyl plank, fiber-cement board, cedar wood shingle and brick veneer
Fiber cement costs $6 to $12 per square foot installed and lasts 50 years or more, vinyl costs $3 to $8 and lasts 20 to 40 years, wood costs $8 to $15 and needs paint every 5 to 7 years, and brick costs $10 to $20 and lasts 75 to 100 years.

Installation, insulation, and house wrap: what happens under the siding

Insist on house wrap and proper flashing, because the siding is the rain screen and the house wrap is the waterproofing — and a siding job without house wrap is a siding job that will rot the wall behind it. House wrap (a spun-bonded polyolefin sheet, the best-known brand is Tyvek) is stapled or nailed to the sheathing before the siding goes on, with the seams taped and the bottom edge lapped over the foundation. It costs $0.50 to $1.00 per square foot installed and it is the single most important layer in the wall — it stops wind-driven rain that gets behind the siding from reaching the sheathing, while still letting water vapor escape from inside the house. Flashing is the metal or plastic that directs water away from windows, doors, and the top of the wall: every window and door needs flashing above it (called head flashing), every horizontal joint needs flashing, and the bottom of the wall needs a weep or a drip edge so water can escape. Ask the contractor to show you the house wrap and the flashing before the siding goes on — once the siding is up, you cannot check it, and a contractor who skips the flashing is a contractor whose siding will leak in 5 years.

A siding replacement is also the best opportunity to add insulation, because the walls are exposed and the incremental cost is low. Rigid foam insulation (1 in to 2 in thick, R-5 to R-10) can be installed under the siding for $1 to $2 per square foot, and it cuts heat loss through the walls by 20 to 30 percent — a $1,500 to $3,000 investment that saves $100 to $300 a year on heating and cooling. The foam also flattens the wall surface, which makes the siding look straighter and last longer. If the house has no wall insulation at all (common in homes built before 1970), consider blown-in cellulose or fiberglass in the wall cavities as well, which costs $1,500 to $3,000 for a typical home and is done from the outside while the siding is off. Confirm that the contractor will not cover up a problem: ask him to photograph any rotted sheathing, any insect damage, and any mold he finds, and to show you the photos before he covers them with house wrap. A siding job that hides rot is a siding job that will fail, and a photograph is the only proof you will have that the wall was sound when the siding went on.

Costs by house size and the quote comparison that catches the lowball

Compare three written quotes line by line, because the cheapest siding quote is often the cheapest for a reason — and the reason is usually something that is not in the quote. A complete quote for a 1,500 sq ft siding job should list: the material (brand, profile, color, and quantity in squares), the removal and disposal of the old siding, the house wrap, the flashing, the trim and accessories (starter strip, J-channel, corner posts, soffit and fascia if included), the insulation if any, the sheathing repair allowance, the labor, the permit, and the warranty. A vinyl job for a 1,500 sq ft wall area should total $4,500 to $12,000, a fiber cement job $9,000 to $18,000, a wood job $12,000 to $22,500, and a brick job $15,000 to $30,000. If a quote is 30 percent below the others, check what is missing: it is usually the house wrap, the flashing, the trim, or the sheathing repair allowance — and those items will appear as change orders during the job, at a higher price than if they had been in the quote. If a quote is 30 percent above the others, ask whether it includes premium trim, insulation, or a longer warranty, and decide whether those are worth the premium.

Pay in stages, never in full up front: a standard schedule is 10 to 20 percent deposit, 40 percent when the material is delivered, 30 percent when the siding is installed, and the final 10 percent after the final inspection. Never pay the final balance until you have walked the house with the contractor and checked the work: the siding should be straight (hold a level against a long run — it should not bow more than 1/4 in over 10 ft), the joints should be tight (no gap wider than 1/8 in), the caulk should be continuous around windows and doors, the bottom edge should be 6 in above the ground, and the color should be consistent (check the siding in daylight from across the street, because a color mismatch between two batches shows up at distance). Keep a box of extra siding (one to two squares) in the garage — a siding panel that is damaged in 10 years can be replaced in an hour if you have a matching panel, and it cannot be replaced at all if the color has been discontinued. Ask the contractor for the product warranty in writing: vinyl carries a 25-year to lifetime warranty, fiber cement carries a 30 to 50 year warranty, wood carries no material warranty (the warranty is on the paint), and brick carries a 50 to 100 year warranty — and in every case, the labor warranty is separate and should be at least 2 to 5 years.

The final choice: which siding for which house

Choose vinyl if your budget is under $12,000 and you want a siding you will never paint: it is the best value, it looks good in a light color, and it lasts 20 to 40 years with a wash once a year. Choose fiber cement if you plan to stay in the house for 20 years or more, you live in a wildfire zone or a hail zone, or you want the siding that adds the most resale value — it costs roughly double vinyl, but it lasts more than twice as long and it is the only siding that is both fireproof and insect-proof. Choose wood if you own a historic home, a craftsman, or a farmhouse where the siding is part of the architecture, and you accept that you will paint it every 5 to 7 years — and choose it in a species that suits your climate (cedar in the North, redwood in the West, cypress in the South). Choose brick if you are building new or you want a siding that you will never replace in your lifetime, and you can afford the $15,000 to $30,000 cost and the structural support it needs. Whichever you choose, get three quotes, check the contractor's license and insurance, ask for two references from jobs done 3 to 5 years ago (a siding job that still looks good after 5 years is a siding job that was done right), and confirm the house wrap, the flashing, and the sheathing repair allowance in writing before the work starts. Siding is the skin of your house — it protects everything inside it, and it is the first thing a buyer sees. Choose it for the climate, the maintenance you will actually do, and the house you actually own.

Frequently asked questions

Keep reading

Exterior House Painting: Prep, Weather Windows and Paint That Lasts

How-To

Prep is roughly 80 percent of a lasting exterior paint job, and two coats of quality acrylic paint last 8 to 12 years.

Read the article